The best advice I ever gave
June 20th 2011
Remember Lucy from Peanuts? I always related to her more than any other female character in that comic strip. She was tough, she had a younger brother, she loved a musician, and she picked on other boys. However, my favorite part about Lucy was her entrepreneurial streak. Instead of selling lemonade, she sold advice for 25 cents.
Even though I have made some horrible decisions in my life, people often ask my advice. Either they believe I am knowledgeable about the subject (e.g., teaching, writing) or they know I have had that specific life experience (e.g., dating brilliant assholes). I don’t even consider myself a good listener most of the time, but on one occasion, I gave the best advice ever.
Four years ago, I worked on a research study at UCLA. Due to having two titles (i.e., two jobs, one salary), I had two offices: one on the same floor as my boss Jan and the other in the building’s basement tucked away from the world. In my “private” office, I blasted music, as I audited the research data. Occasionally, I even danced around because there was so much space. I was bopping my head to the music from the Chicago soundtrack, singing the lyrics, my fingers flying across the keyboard when the phone rang. I looked over—it was my boss’s extension. Sighing, I walked to the stereo, turned down the music, and picked up the phone.
“Hi Jan.”
“Hi Andrea. Do you have a minute?” (I love when bosses ask this question as if their employees can say no.)
“Of course.”
“I wanted to ask your advice about something.” Jan paused. Her hesitation piqued my curiosity.
I replied, “Sure. Go ahead.” I could almost hear her foot tapping under her desk.
“Well, I thought … maybe since …” Each pause annoyed me. I wished she would just spit it out already.
“There’s a mother. Lydia. She has four children. She’s in group 2 on Saturdays.” I didn’t work on Saturdays so I had never met Lydia.
I responded, “Uh huh” as I picked at my cuticles and eyed the stack of paperwork that still needed to be processed.
“She left me a message. She hasn’t been feeling well lately. Horrible headaches, fatigue. Umm … She has an inoperable brain tumor. She has cancer. She is dying.”
My body froze even as my hand gripped the phone so tight that my veins popped out. Why was my boss telling me this? She knew what had happened. I didn’t want to hear the “c” word … oohhh … it’s because of my experience. Damn her.
Jan continued. “I thought … because of your sister … you would know what to say. If it’s okay that is … I wanted to know what you think I should say to Lydia.”
Me? My boss was asking me for my advice? About talking to a cancer patient? I should have been flattered, but instead I felt like actor on a stage with a spotlight shining on me as I searched my memory for my lines. I closed my eyes and thought of the stupid things well-intentioned people said to me when Adrienne was sick.
- “Have faith.” Faith in what and in whom?
- “Things will get better.” Really? Can you personally stop the tumors from multiplying? Because the chemo can’t.
- And my all-time favorite, “God only gives you what you can handle.” So my sister got cancer because she is a strong, vibrant person. Yeah, go sell that shit somewhere else.
“Andrea?” Jan almost whispered my name.
Knocked out of my reverie, I answered, “Tell me about Lydia.” Jan described Lydia’s devotion to her four children—her desire to provide them with a better life, to give them a good education, to allow them opportunities that she never had. I could tell by the tone in Jan’s voice that she admired Lydia. I wanted so desperately to say the perfect thing because I didn’t want Lydia to feel any anger, resentment, or disappointment toward Jan. If I were Lydia …
Taking a deep breath, I plunged forward hoping my bluntness wouldn’t get me fired.
“When you call her, the only thing you should say—that you can say—about her disease is ‘I’m sorry.’ Don’t say anything else. Start with ‘I’m sorry’ and move on. Focus on what you told me. Talk about her qualities as a mother. She respects your opinion. It will mean a lot to her knowing that you think so highly of her. And … tell her that her children will remember her—especially the older ones.”
Jan thanked me, said goodbye, and hung up the phone. I sat there listening to the dial tone wondering what just happened. Wondering how many people had already said the wrong things to Lydia. Wondering if she had her affairs in order. Wondering who would take care of her children. I finally put the phone down. I did not play music. I did not dance. I stared at the paperwork. Eventually, I started typing. The phone rang. I knew it was Jan.
“I just spoke to Lydia. Thank you, Andrea. Your advice—it was perfect. We had a lovely conversation. She thinks her older children will remember her, too.”
“Good. I’m glad … I mean, you’re welcome.” I controlled my sniffling but I couldn’t stop the one tear from falling down my cheek. Jan and I exchanged goodbyes and I hung up the phone for the second time in twenty minutes. Then I cried. I cried for Lydia because she would never see her children grow up. I cried for her children because they would lose their mother. I cried for Adrienne because I think she would have been proud of me.
With my eyes still swimming in water, I started laughing. I had just given the best advice I would probably ever give in my life, and it was to my boss. Not to my husband or a friend, but my boss. How absurd! Remembering the Chicago soundtrack, I walked over to the stereo. I pressed the PLAY button on the CD player.
Pop!
Six!
Squish!
Uh Uh
Cicero
Lipschitiz!
I smiled as the beginning sounds of the Cell Block Tango filled the room. I turned up the volume.
He had it coming
He had it coming
He only had himself to blame …
I sang. I danced. And I cried again.
AWW — XoXo




















